Why the Victorian State Government Parliamentary inquiry must and will fail
Note: This letter is in reference to the Victorian government’s inquiry into the abuse of children by religious and other organizations. -MD
A parliamentary inquiry cannot be deemed independent due to:
a) government complicity in the crimes
b) investigating politicians are not and can not ever be secular due to a belief in
the god of the religions under review.
Independence for this inquiry would mean that those investigating these crimes
should not be a part of the government due to its involvement in the crimes or
religious (Jewish, Christian, Muslim or other religion) due to involvement in the
Therefore a parliamentary inquiry will never find on behalf of the victims as it can
never consider the possibility that there is no god and that therefore the catholic
church is therefore a fraud. It can and will never be able to consider the church as
a deluded psychological abusive criminal cult with dominionist and sexual obsessions
that is capable of stealing and selling children, blackmailing and abusing women and
children, bullying and intimidating itself into a position of power and authority in
all aspects of the state and society nor can it ever recommend the suspension of any
activity of a religious belief regardless of the extent of the atrocities through
the use of religion and belief that is presented to an inquiry made up of those with
an unstinting, unswerving belief in the religion or its practices.
A believing parliamentarian cannot even consider the possibility that religion can
be wrong let alone give consideration from the perspective of there being no god
while any of its members believe in the in-errancy, infallibility, eternal
punishment, biblical judgment or other beliefs of their own religion. Such a body
should never be called to investigate crimes carried out by religion and by
A true independent can only come from those who have no belief in the god of the
religions under review and preferably from those who were not indoctrinated into the
religion before they were able to freely choose for themselves.
This parliamentary inquiry can not be considered to be secular in any manner
what-so-ever. The parliamentary inquiry will never be capable of finding against the
beliefs of a religion of members of the inquiry therefore the inquiry can never
determine the truth nor can it find in favor of those survivors and victims who have
no belief in the god or the religion that was used to abuse them and the religion of
those inquiring into those abuses.
Religious believers are simply not capable of conducting this investigation in an
independent manner, nor are thy capable of providing justice for victims and
survivors who are now atheists and non-blievers; will their assessment of what is a
fair and just response towards atheist and non-believer survivors be measured by the
religious beliefs of those making up the inquiry that specifically exclude and
The testimony of atheist survivors simply cannot be accepted nor considered equally
for validation and investigation by believers in the religions under question as the
veracity of the witness due to their non-belief is already cast through the
teachings and beliefs of the religions of the inquirers.
Under such a circumstance the findings of the inquiry can be determined before it
concludes that it must find against atheist survivors and therefore in favor of
their abusers on the basis of religious belief.
The inquiry is already a sham and a fraud as the inquiry begins its life with a
polluted and toxic environment due to a predetermined religious bias against atheist
survivors and their testimonies.